Thursday previews are in, and Sunrise on the Reaping is right on track for the $100M+ opening we were expecting on Thursday. It made $21.25M, which is $5M from the early access shows in premium formats on Wednesday night plus $16.25M from regular previews that started at noon on Thursday.
Sunrise on the Reaping: $21.25M previews, $105–120M weekend. That’s the second-biggest preview number the franchise has ever done, behind only Catching Fire’s $25.0M, and the second-biggest of the year after Spider-Man: Brand New Day’s $72M. It’s also comfortably ahead of The Odyssey’s $17.6M, and Nolan’s film went on to open to $123.5M. The Hunger Games films have been really consistent at turning their previews into an opening weekend, with Catching Fire doing 6.3x, Mockingjay Part 2 6.4x and Mockingjay Part 1 7.2x. Since this number has the Wednesday shows baked in, we’re only applying those multiples to the Thursday part, and that gets it to somewhere between $107M and $122M.
The case for the lower end is just how much of a fan crowd this is. Breaking Dawn Part 1 only managed 4.6x its $30.3M Thursday, and if Sunrise ends up anywhere near that front-loaded it would land closer to the $85M Lionsgate itself has been quoting. We don’t really see that happening here though. The audience score is sitting at 95% on Rotten Tomatoes, so the people who went last night are going to be telling their friends to go, and that should keep Saturday from falling off too much. We’re sticking with around $110M, with $120M still very much in play, which would give Lionsgate its biggest opening since Mockingjay Part 1 back in 2014.
This is the weekend November has been waiting for. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens on Friday, and a month after we wrote it up as a $50–70M opener, the conversation has moved all the way up to whether it can get back to the $100M openings the franchise was doing a decade ago. Underneath it, I Play Rocky goes wide off two weekends in limited release and should give Ebenezer a real fight for second. The top ten made just $73.0M last weekend, and this one should come close to doubling that, although it won’t catch the same frame last year, when Wicked: For Good opened to $147.0M on its own and the top ten did $178.6M.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
In our November preview we had this opening somewhere between $50M and $75M, and we said a $75M+ start was the version where everything goes right. Since then presales have gone on a pretty incredible run. They’re now the best Lionsgate has seen for anything since the pandemic, including Michael, and tracking has gone from $60–70M at the start of the month to $90–120M this week, with some in exhibition talking about $125M. Early access screenings in premium formats start tonight, with regular previews from noon on Thursday.
It’s worth walking through just how far this franchise had fallen to appreciate what’s happening here. The Hunger Games opened to $152.5M in 2012, Catching Fire went up to $158.1M, and then it started coming down, with Mockingjay Part 1 at $121.9M and Part 2 at $102.7M on this exact weekend in 2015. Eight years later The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes opened to just $44.6M, ending with a solid $166M, but way down from the previous heights. A sixth movie in any franchise is supposed to keep sliding from there. Instead this one has a much loved book behind it, a cast full of big names, and the whole weekend to itself (Ballad had to share its premium screens with Trolls Band Together), and it looks set to more than double its predecessor’s opening.
The one real question is how front-loaded it gets. The audience here is heavily young women, which is the same crowd that drove both Wicked films, and those two went in very different directions: Wicked opened to $112.5M and fell just 28% over Thanksgiving, while Wicked: For Good opened to $147.0M and fell 58%. The Twilight films are the extreme version, with Breaking Dawn Part 1 doing $30.3M from its Thursday alone and then falling 70% over Thanksgiving. Reviews are decent at 76% on Rotten Tomatoes, which is perfectly fine for a sixth entry, but it isn’t the kind of score that pulls in casual fans on opening weekend all by itself. While presales give it a genuine shot at $120M, we think a fan-driven opening with a big Thursday ends up a bit more compressed than that, and we’re expecting it to land around $110M. That would make it the fifth $100M opening of the year, and Lionsgate’s biggest start since the Mockingjay films, comfortably past Michael’s $97.2M. It’s worth noting that there’s still a very realistic shot at $120M, and we won’t be shocked if it gets there. The new range now feels like $100–120M, so that represents the upper end.
From there, Thanksgiving next weekend is what makes or breaks the run. Every Hunger Games film that opened in November dropped around 50% over the holiday, apart from Ballad, which fell just 35% off a much smaller base. It also loses its AMC IMAX screens to Netflix’s Cliff Booth on Wednesday, though it keeps its IMAX screens at most of the other big chains. A Mockingjay-style 2.7x from $110M gets it to around $300M, which would pass Part 2’s $281.7M and make this the biggest Hunger Games film in over a decade. Globally it’s set for a start north of $150M and possibly $200M+, which is looking more and more likely. On a $150M budget anything past $500M worldwide makes a seventh film close to a certainty. At this point that looks very doable and it’s a fantastic turnaround for a franchise that looked like it was winding down three years ago.
I Play Rocky
After two weekends in limited release and about $1M so far, Peter Farrelly’s movie about Sylvester Stallone fighting to star in his own Rocky script goes out to around 2,000 theaters this weekend. The reviews have stayed strong at 88% on Rotten Tomatoes from 152 critics, with a 98% audience score, and tracking has it somewhere around $10–13M. That’s a great number for this kind of film. Rocky Balboa opened to $12.2M in 2006, The Fighter did $12.1M, and A Complete Unknown opened to $11.7M from 2,835 theaters two Christmases ago and went on to $75.0M. We think this one goes slightly higher than all three of those and breaks out of its tracking range, too.
Its own platform run hasn’t really told us much, as it only went from seven theaters to 29 last weekend and averaged $17,024, which is solid without being anything special. The bigger thing working for it is the calendar, as it’s the biggest new option this weekend for older audiences, and next week is Thanksgiving, which is exactly when a crowd-pleaser like this plays best. The lower theatre count makes getting to $20M tougher, but we do see breakout potential here, so it definitely has a shot at mid teens on its way to a great hold over Thanksgiving. After How to Rob a Bank fell flat last weekend, that would be a really good result for Amazon MGM, and with this audience score it should have legs well into December.
Ebenezer
After landing at #1 with $19.0M last weekend, Ebenezer’s second weekend is where we’ll find out how much the A- CinemaScore is really worth. Paramount has only sent Monday so far, which came in at $1.4M, down 72% from Sunday. That’s a fairly normal Monday for an adult-skewing film in mid-November, so it doesn’t tell us a lot either way.
The comp we keep coming back to is Murder on the Orient Express, which opened on this same weekend in 2017 and fell 52% in its second weekend up against Justice League, then dropped just 5% over Thanksgiving. The Jim Carrey A Christmas Carol is the best case, falling just 26%, but that one didn’t have a franchise juggernaut opening on top of it, or a well reviewed Stallone biopic going after the same older crowd. Somewhere around 50% gets it to $9.5M and around $34M by Sunday, which keeps it on track for the $60M we said in the recap. That being said, we’re expecting a harsher fall than 50% this weekend, mostly thanks to the competition, potentially closer to 55–60%. Either way, on a $38M budget it’s already doing well enough for Paramount. Next weekend’s hold is the real make or break, as this has the potential to start holding like a Christmas movie. We’ll see if it gets there or not.
The Cat in the Hat
The Cat in the Hat has had the family audience pretty much to itself for two weeks now, and this is the last weekend that’s true, with Hexed arriving on Wednesday. Its weekdays look rough at first glance, with Tuesday down 58% on last Tuesday, but last Tuesday was the night before Veterans Day with kids off school, so it isn’t a clean comparison. Sunrise on the Reaping is PG-13 and will pull some of the older kids and teens away, so we’re expecting a drop in the low 40s, around $6.5M, which gets it close to $47M by Sunday. That keeps it on track for the $70M we called on Sunday, if it can get a nice bump over Thanksgiving, which is a decent result, just well under the potential here - this easily could have popped to $100M+.
Godzilla Minus Zero
After its 72% drop last weekend, things have at least settled down a bit for Godzilla. Monday and Tuesday were both down around 70% on the week before, although that week had Veterans Day doing a lot of the work. It’s at $50.8M through Tuesday, $6.3M short of Godzilla Minus One’s $57.1M, and losing the last of its premium screens to Sunrise on the Reaping means another drop in the 50s, around $4M. That leaves it just short of Minus One on Sunday, and it should pass it over Thanksgiving on its way to around $60–65M. We knew this would be more front-loaded, and it looks like a similar final result (just slightly higher) as Minus One, just concentrated into a much bigger opening weekend. That’s still a great result for a Japanese-language film on a $15M budget.
Holdovers and the rest
Ramayana: Rise of a Legend had one of the best holds in the top five last weekend, and it’s still doing really well on weekdays, with Tuesday up 90% on Monday to $835K. It’s already at $25.7M, and a drop around 40% gets it to $3.5M and around $30M by Sunday, comfortably on its way past the $33M we called in the recap. You Can See Everything is at $89.0M through the weekend and should do around $3.5M with another drop in the 30s, which leaves it within a million or two of Marty Supreme’s $96.0M by Sunday, so it should become A24’s second-biggest film ever over Thanksgiving and become just their second ever to cross $100M domestic.
Wild Horse Nine is holding up very well after nearly doubling its theaters, with Monday down just 12% on last Monday, and should do around $3M. Ghost Soldier is at $9.4M after Tuesday and should fall around 50% to $2.5M.
Neon also takes Paper Tiger wide after a $219K start in six theaters last weekend, the best per-theater average James Gray has ever had. It’s sitting at 86% on Rotten Tomatoes with Adam Driver, Miles Teller and Scarlett Johansson, but Neon hasn’t confirmed a theater count and there’s no real tracking for it, and Gray’s films have never been big openers outside of Ad Astra ($19.0M) with Brad Pitt. We’re thinking around $3M, and its real test is how it holds through the holidays as awards season picks up. In limited release, Focus has Elsinore, with Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson, at 89% from 73 reviews.
Looking ahead
Thanksgiving is next, with Disney’s Hexed and Universal’s Focker-in-Law both opening on Wednesday and tracking at $50–60M and $40–50M over the five days. Club Kid and Bitter Christmas go wide the same day, Angel has Hershey, and Netflix’s The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth takes over AMC’s IMAX screens, so Sunrise on the Reaping’s second weekend is going to be a genuinely busy one as we wrap up November.
The recap for this weekend publishes Sunday, November 22.
