After the busiest weekend since September, things calm down a little before The Hunger Games arrives next week. Johnny Depp is back in a studio lead for the first time in eight years with Ti West’s Ebenezer, which should take #1 pretty comfortably without needing a huge number to do it. The more interesting race is right behind it, where Godzilla Minus Zero and The Cat in the Hat could end up finishing within a million dollars of each other. The top ten made $102.9M last weekend and we won’t get close to that again, but this frame last year only did $67.0M with Now You See Me: Now You Don’t on top at $21.0M, and with all the depth from last weekend’s openers still in play, this weekend should clear that easily.
Ebenezer
When we wrote our November preview, tracking for this one was sitting at $25–35M and we thought that was too high, calling $10–20M. Since then the two have pretty much met in the middle, with tracking coming down to around $20–25M and presales looking pretty solid. One of the comps being thrown around is Karate Kid: Legends, which opened to $20.3M last year, and that feels about right to us.
The Depp question is the one everybody will be asking on Sunday. His last studio film was Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald in 2018, and the last time he carried a non-franchise studio film on his own name it was Black Mass, which opened to $22.6M in 2015 and finished at $62.6M. Either side of that were Dark Shadows at $29.7M, Transcendence at $10.9M and Mortdecai at $4.2M, so his drawing power was already fading well before he disappeared from studio films. A $20M+ start in 2026, for a gothic Christmas Carol from the director of X and Pearl, would be a much better answer than most people expected a year ago. It’d also be around three times the biggest opening Ti West has ever had, which was MaXXXine at $6.7M.
What makes this different from a normal $20M opener is the calendar. A Christmas movie opening six weeks before Christmas gets to play the whole season if people like it. The 2009 Jim Carrey A Christmas Carol opened to $30.1M on the first weekend of November, fell just 26% in its second weekend and finished at $138.0M, a 4.6x multiplier. Murder on the Orient Express, another period piece for older audiences with Depp in it, opened to $28.7M on this same weekend in 2017, dropped 52% in its second weekend, then just 5% over Thanksgiving, and got to $102.8M on 3.6x legs. Violent Night did 3.7x from a December start. Even the low end of those gets a $21M opening to around $75M, which is the number we put on it back in October.
The catch is that we’re going in pretty blind on reviews. Rotten Tomatoes has one review as of Wednesday night, and the early social reactions are mostly positive on Depp, with a couple of people really hating the film. It also only cost $38M to make, with a reported $50M spent on marketing, so Paramount doesn’t need a huge number here.
While there’s a real chance the over-35 crowd turns up for the comeback the way it did for Practical Magic 2’s $30.0M back in September, we ultimately think this lands right around where tracking has it, at $20M or a touch over, and the hold next weekend is where we’ll really find out what this is. A B+ or better CinemaScore and it plays all the way through December, whereas anything in the C range makes it more like a $50M movie. Either way, anything over $20M is a genuinely good start for everyone involved here.
Godzilla Minus Zero
In the recap we said it was safe to expect a pretty steep second weekend, and nothing in the weekdays so far changes that. Monday fell 68% from Sunday to $2.1M and Tuesday bounced back 58% to $3.3M, which is a pretty normal Tuesday bump with a little help from it being the night before Veterans Day. It’s at $36.0M after five days. The opening weekend also came in a little lower on actuals at $30.6M, which leaves it about $1M behind Godzilla vs. Kong’s $31.6M.
The second weekends for this franchise are all over the place. Minus One fell just 25% because nobody knew about it on opening weekend. Godzilla vs. Kong fell 56%, Godzilla x Kong 61% and King of the Monsters 68%. The anime openings we used as comps last week were steeper again, with Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle down 76%. Minus Zero’s opening was front-loaded like the anime films, but it also has a 96% audience score and an A CinemaScore, and some of the tracking out there has it holding under 50%. The problem is Thursday, when Dune and Dune: Part Two take the IMAX screens back.
While the audience scores do give it a shot at a hold in the low 50s, we’re being more conservative here and see it falling closer to 60%, somewhere around $12–13M, which is why we think second place is genuinely up for grabs. Either way, it passes The Boy and the Heron’s $46.8M this weekend to become GKIDS’ biggest film ever, and it’ll pass Minus One’s $57.1M next week, which is a fantastic result for a Japanese-language film. Our model still has it at $89.3–97.3M on 2.95x legs, but we’re sticking with the $75–80M we said on Sunday.
The Cat in the Hat
Unlike Godzilla, this one was built for a second weekend. Its Saturday jumped 41% from Friday last weekend, the biggest increase in the top ten, and Tuesday was up 124% on Monday to $1.8M with kids off school on Wednesday for Veterans Day. With an A CinemaScore, an 87% audience score and Wildwood as the only other family film in the market, we’re looking at a drop somewhere in the 30s, which gets it to around $13M.
The comps for a hold like that are good ones. Coyote vs. Acme fell 25% in its second weekend, although that was Labor Day so it isn’t quite apples to apples, and The Grinch fell 41% on this same weekend in 2018 off an opening more than three times as big. Most of the tracking has Godzilla staying ahead thanks to its premium screens, but we think it’s a lot closer than that, and we wouldn’t be shocked if The Cat in the Hat ends up taking second. Our model has it finishing at $69.1–77.1M on 3.57x legs, which still isn’t enough on an $86M budget for Warner Bros., but a hold in the 30s here keeps it on enough screens to get the Thanksgiving bump, and that’s really what this weekend is about for it.
How to Rob a Bank
In our November preview we said this one would live or die on reviews, and they’re in at 43% on Rotten Tomatoes from 35 reviews. Tracking has gone the same way, starting at $10–15M three weeks ago and now sitting at $6–10M, with some as low as $3.5M. We said $12M ish at the time, and that’s long gone now.
David Leitch’s films have been getting bigger budgets for roughly the same result. Atomic Blonde opened to $18.3M, Bullet Train to $30.0M and The Fall Guy to $27.7M on a $130M budget, finishing at $92.9M. Those had Charlize Theron, Brad Pitt and Ryan Gosling out front. Nicholas Hoult’s own openings as a lead are The Menu at $9.0M and Renfield at $8.0M, and Amazon MGM’s other heist film this year, Crime 101, opened to $14.3M with Chris Hemsworth and finished at $36.6M.
Tracking does suggest it could get to $8M or higher, but with reviews this soft and two other new releases going after a similar audience, we’re thinking it lands closer to $6M. On a budget that’s been reported anywhere between $40M and $60M, that’s a tough result for Amazon MGM, in the same month they have I Play Rocky going wide.
You Can See Everything
A -26% hold against three new wide openers last weekend was the best argument yet that $100M is on the table. It passed March of the Penguins and is now the second-biggest documentary we track, with only Fahrenheit 9/11 ($119.0M) ahead. With Ebenezer going after the same older audience this weekend, we’re expecting a similar drop to last weekend, somewhere around $6–7M, which puts it at $90M or so by Sunday. Our model has it at $88.5–106.8M, and passing Marty Supreme’s $96.0M to become A24’s second-biggest film ever is looking more and more likely, which is a pretty incredible result for a $7M documentary.
Ghost Soldier
Sony moved this from last Friday to Veterans Day, so it has two days in the bank before the weekend even starts. Tracking has climbed from $4–6M two weeks ago to as high as $6–10M. Jim Caviezel’s last big release was Sound of Freedom, which opened to $19.7M and got to $184.2M, but that was a phenomenon and this is a straight action movie from the director of Land of Bad, which opened to $1.8M. Reviews are split, with four positive out of eight so far. The faith and military crowd should do most of the work here, and so we’re thinking around $4M for the weekend and $6M over the five days, with a shot at more if Wednesday comes in big.
Holdovers and the rest
Wildwood keeps finding people. It fell just 20% to $7.2M last weekend, and although its Monday and Tuesday were down 46% and 44% on the week before, last Tuesday was Election Day, so that isn’t a clean read. Another -25% or so gets it $5–6M and past $50M next week. Drummer Boy had the flattest Sunday in the top ten last weekend, down just 6% from Saturday, but Angel’s films usually fall hard in weekend two (Young Washington was down 64%), so we’re at $4.5–5.5M. Ramayana has been the #2 film in the market on both Monday and Tuesday, ahead of The Cat in the Hat, and is already at $15.9M. Indian films are usually very front-loaded here (Kalki 2898 AD fell 69% in its second weekend), so we’re looking at around $3.5–5M. Clayface should do around $4M and get to around $64M, and Wild Horse Nine should also be around $4M as it expands in its second weekend.
Bleecker Street’s Victorian Psycho, with Maika Monroe, opens at 78% on Rotten Tomatoes with tracking at $2.5–5M. In limited release, Neon has Paper Tiger (86%) ahead of going wide next weekend, and Sony Pictures Classics has Bitter Christmas (84%).
Looking ahead
Next weekend is the big one for November. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens on the 20th, and tracking keeps climbing, with some now talking about $100M+, which would be more than double The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes’ $44.6M opening. I Play Rocky and Paper Tiger both go wide the same day, and then it’s Hexed and Focker-in-Law for Thanksgiving.
With The Hunger Games a week away, this was always going to be a bit of a breather, and that’s pretty much what we got. Ebenezer gave Johnny Depp his first #1 opening since 2018 with $19.0M, which is right at the bottom of where tracking had it but comes with some really encouraging signs for the weeks ahead. The real movement was underneath it: Godzilla Minus Zero fell a massive 72% and handed second place to The Cat in the Hat, How to Rob a Bank and Ghost Soldier finished just $82K apart off very different budgets, and Ramayana and Wild Horse Nine both held better than pretty much everything that opened alongside them last week.
The top ten came to $73.0M, down 29% from last weekend’s $102.9M, which is still about 9% ahead of the same frame last year, when Now You See Me: Now You Don’t opened to $21.0M on top of a $67.0M weekend. All in all, it’s a solid enough placeholder weekend before Sunrise on the Reaping and Thanksgiving kick things into another gear.
Ebenezer
Going into the weekend we had this at $19–24M and thought it would land at $20M or a touch over, and it came in right at the floor of that with $19.0M from 3,535 theaters. That’s a little under where tracking had settled, but it’s still Depp’s best start as a lead since Black Mass opened to $22.6M in 2015, and it’s close to three times anything Ti West has opened before (MaXXXine did $6.7M).
The shape of the weekend is the really encouraging part. Friday was $6.85M including $1.5M from Thursday previews, Saturday went up 7% to $7.3M and Sunday fell 33% to $4.9M. Take the previews out and Saturday was up 36% on the true Friday, which is the opposite of the fan-driven, front-loaded opening we saw from Godzilla last weekend. Audiences gave it an A- CinemaScore and it’s sitting at 90% with audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, against just 54% from critics. The crowd was mostly adults too, with 59% of the audience over 30 and families making up just 9%, so there’s still room for it to broaden out as we get closer to Christmas.
Where it goes from here is the whole story. Our model opens at $52.6–60.6M on 2.98x legs, but the model treats this like any other pre-Thanksgiving drama and has no way of knowing it’s a Christmas Carol. The 2009 Jim Carrey version opened to $30.1M on the first weekend of November, fell 26% in its second weekend and finished at $138.0M on 4.6x legs. Murder on the Orient Express, the other older-skewing period piece with Depp in it, opened to $28.7M on this exact weekend in 2017 and got to $102.8M on 3.6x legs. Even the lower of those two puts Ebenezer at around $68M.
Sunrise on the Reaping and Hexed are going to take a lot of screens over the next two weekends, which is the main thing working against it, but we think the A- and the Christmas setting carry this past the top of the model to somewhere around $65–70M. Worldwide it starts at $42.0M with $23.0M from overseas, and on a $38M budget that makes this a really solid start for Paramount, and a genuinely good comeback for Depp.
The Cat in the Hat
We thought the race for second would be a lot closer than most people did, and it ended up going The Cat in the Hat’s way pretty comfortably, although that says more about Godzilla than anything this did. It fell 44% to $11.3M, a little worse than the drop in the 30s we were expecting, and still finished $2.8M ahead. Saturday more than doubled Friday (+115%), the biggest Saturday jump in the top ten for the second week in a row, which is exactly what a family film looks like when kids are back in school on Friday.
A -44% drop is fine without being anything special. The Grinch fell 41% on this same weekend in 2018, and The Cat in the Hat also had Veterans Day pulling some of its weekend forward, as it was the #1 film in the country on Wednesday with $3.5M. It’s at $38.1M domestic and $51.3M worldwide, and our model tightened to $70.5–78.5M on 3.73x legs after the second weekend.
It does have the family audience mostly to itself until Hexed arrives on the 25th, which is why the Thanksgiving bump we talked about last week is still very much in play, but with a drop in the 40s here we’re thinking it ends up at the low end of the model, right around $70M. That’s a respectable recovery from where the opening left it, but still a tough result for Warner Bros. on an $86M budget.
Godzilla Minus Zero
This was our biggest miss of the weekend. We said the second weekend would be steep and had it falling closer to 60%, and instead it fell 72% to $8.5M. That’s worse than any of the American Godzillas (King of the Monsters fell 68%, Godzilla x Kong 61% and Godzilla vs. Kong 56%) and right down with the anime openings we used as comps last week, where Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle fell 76%. Friday was down 85% on its opening day. The IMAX screens went back to the Dune re-releases on Thursday, and it’s pretty clear now that most of the people who wanted to see this had already gone on opening weekend.
It still got what it came for, though. At $49.1M it has passed The Boy and the Heron’s $46.8M to become the biggest film GKIDS has ever released, and it’s just $8.0M away from Godzilla Minus One’s $57.1M. Worldwide it has crossed $80M.
Our model moved to $72.6–80.6M on 2.50x legs, which is the same 2.5x we talked about in last Sunday’s recap, but a film that just did $8.5M would need to find another $23M+ to get there and we don’t see that happening with The Hunger Games taking its audience on Friday. We’re now expecting it to end up around $60M, just past Minus One, which is well short of the $75–80M we said a week ago. Even so, that’s a great result for a Japanese-language film on a $15M budget, and it’ll be the biggest Japanese Godzilla run we’ve ever had here once it gets past Minus One.
Ramayana: Rise of a Legend
While Godzilla dropped like an anime film, Ramayana did the opposite of what Indian films usually do here. They’re normally close to done by their second weekend (Kalki 2898 AD fell 69%), which is why we had this at $3.5–5M, and it beat that comfortably with $5.8M and a drop of just 35%, even after losing 323 theaters. It finished as the #4 film in the country from only 1,110 locations, ahead of You Can See Everything. It’s at $24.4M domestic and is now well past $100M worldwide. We said $20–30M last weekend and it’s clearly going to end up above that now, likely somewhere around $33M, which is a really strong result and more evidence of how big Indian films are becoming in this market.
You Can See Everything
After two weekends of holding better than we expected, this was the first one that came in a little under, with a 35% drop to $5.5M against the $6–7M we had. It lost 628 theaters, down to 1,845, and Ebenezer was going after the same older audience, so it’s still a pretty strong hold all things considered. It’s at $89.0M, which leaves just $7.0M to Marty Supreme’s $96.0M and the title of A24’s second-biggest film ever. Our model still has it at $88.5–106.8M. It should get past Marty Supreme in the next couple of weeks, but with theaters dropping off this quickly, $100M is going to be really close, and we’re thinking it ends up just short at around $97–98M. Either way, it’s an incredible run for a $7M documentary.
How to Rob a Bank
Two films opened $82K apart this weekend and only one of them is a good result. Amazon MGM’s How to Rob a Bank did $5.2M from 2,810 theaters, right at the bottom of our $5–8M and a little under the $6M we thought it would do. Friday was $2.2M including $900K in previews, Saturday fell 20% and Sunday another 36%, with a B- CinemaScore and 34% on Rotten Tomatoes. Crime 101, Amazon MGM’s other heist film this year, opened to $14.3M and finished at $36.6M. With The Hunger Games taking most of its screens on Friday, this is looking at a total of around $12M, which is a rough result on a budget that’s been reported anywhere from $40M to $60M.
Ghost Soldier
Sony’s Ghost Soldier, on the other hand, did $5.1M for the weekend and $8.2M since its Veterans Day opening, above the $4M and $6M we had, and it cost just $18M. Audiences have it at 90% against 36% from critics, and Wednesday’s $2.3M is still its biggest day, so the Veterans Day move clearly worked out for Sony here.
Wild Horse Nine
Searchlight went from 1,100 theaters to 2,175 and Wild Horse Nine fell just 23% to $4.5M, a little ahead of the $4M we had. Saturday was down only 8% on last Saturday. It’s at $13.2M domestic and $28.2M worldwide, and with awards season still to come this should keep ticking along nicely through Thanksgiving, on its way to $25M or more.
Further down
Wildwood finally had a normal drop, falling 39% to $4.4M after losing 525 theaters, which is under the $5–6M we had and the biggest drop of its run so far. It’s at $48.4M and will cross $50M this week. Clayface fell 45% to $3.7M and is at $63.6M, right where we said it would be. Drummer Boy dropped 64% to $3.4M and fell out of the top ten, the exact same second weekend drop Young Washington had over the summer. Wicker lost 900 theaters and fell 56% to $1.5M for $23.3M, and Victorian Psycho opened outside the top ten with $1.1M from 1,206 theaters, well under what tracking had.
In limited release, A24’s Club Kid rose 87% to $756K from 27 theaters, a $28,002 average, and Neon’s Paper Tiger opened to $219K from six theaters ($36,501 each) ahead of going wide on Friday.
Looking ahead
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens on Friday, and tracking has shot up to $80M+ and as high as $100–120M, with presales reportedly running ahead of Wicked’s, compared to the $44.6M that The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes opened to in 2023. I Play Rocky and Paper Tiger go wide the same day, and then it’s Hexed and Focker-in-Law for Thanksgiving.
